Astrophotography diagnosis of N?buleuse de la Grotte: Residual vignetting, green cast and 3 others

MasterIr/Uv cut49×180s13 oct. 2026

The Doc examined this image of N?buleuse de la Grotte (master, Ir/Uv cut, 49×180s). Estimated overall technical quality: 5/10. 5 defects found: Residual vignetting (severity 3/5), Green cast (severity 3/5), Tracking drift (severity 2/5), Residual hot and cold pixels (severity 2/5), Noise / underexposure (severity 2/5).

Annotated image
Click to zoom

Info

Cible
N?buleuse de la Grotte
Date
13 oct. 2026, 20:12
Lune
Gibbeuse décroissante 89.9% (sous l'horizon)
Site
Bortle 3 · rural peu pollué (saisi)
Position
22h59m20s · +62°22'29"

Conditions were excellent and are not to blame. The Moon, although 89.9% gibbous, was below the horizon during the session and 122 degrees from the target, so it contributed nothing to the sky background. The stated Bortle 3 is a rare quality sky that allows broadband work (IR/UV cut) on an emission nebula like Sh2-155, with no need to switch to dual-band. In that context the green background and the peripheral falloff come from the optical train and the missing calibration, not from the sky. You can capitalize on this: under such a sky, lengthening subs to 300 s and accumulating more hours will pay off directly, with no risk of swamping the background.

- the Doc

Setup

Type d'image
Master
Télescope
C11+Hyper+Uranus
Caméra
Poseidon-C PRO
Filtre
Ir/Uv cut
Monture
AZ EQ6
Exposition
49×180s
Phase de lune
Premier croissant (7 %)
Notes
Stack sans DOF
FOV
2.49°

The setup is well matched to the target. At 540 mm and 1.436 arcsec/px the sampling is comfortable for typical seeing, and the measured FWHM of 3.9 to 4.8 px (5.6 to 6.9 arcsec) point to average seeing or slight drift rather than a sampling problem. The 2.49 degree field frames Sh2-155 with room to spare; the composition leaves the nebula off-center toward the upper left but fully contained. Gain 125 and offset 50 are healthy, with no dark clipping (0%) and only 0.02% saturated. The -20C sensor temperature is very good. The real weakness is procedural rather than optical: the large 6252x4176 sensor behind a C11 absolutely requires flats, and the 180 s exposure leaves a low background-to-black-point margin (1.79), so it is barely sky-limited under Bortle 3.

- the Doc

The diagnosis in detail

Everything stems from one choice: stacking without darks, flats or bias. That alone explains three of the findings. First, the 25% illumination falloff from center to edges, perfectly radial (R2=0.89, anisotropy 0.02), the signature of uncorrected optical vignetting on a large sensor behind a C11. Second, the scattering of isolated hot pixels, which darks would have subtracted and dithering would have diluted. Third, part of the background noise, since the missing bias degrades the master signal-to-noise ratio.

The second axis is color. The distinctly olive background and greenish stars are the mark of an uncalibrated linear master. The DSS comparison is conclusive: where the reference shows structured orange nebulosity with dark nebulae southwest of Sh2-155, your image barely hints at red around the central cavity. The signal is there, it is simply buried under the cast and under a noise level still high for 2h27 of integration.

Finally, on the mechanical side, the PSF panel shows elongation present from the center (1.13 against a 1.05 floor) with consistent position angles across the field (12.7 degree dispersion). This is not a field aberration but tracking drift, moderate, worsening slightly toward the BR corner. Nothing crippling, but refined polar alignment and guiding would make the stars noticeably tighter.

Priority actions

  1. Re-stack with flats, dark-flats and darks at -20C gain 125 180s, which fixes vignetting and hot pixels at once
  2. Apply photometric color calibration (SPCC or Color Calibration) then a green SCNR to remove the olive cast
  3. Enable dithering between subs in the NINA sequence for future sessions
  4. Check polar alignment and PHD2 guiding curves to bring center elongation below 1.10
  5. Accumulate 6 to 8 hours total on Sh2-155, with 300 s subs since the Bortle 3 sky allows it